Nestled along the scenic coast of Eastham, MA, the search for the perfect bagel can feel like a weekend adventure. Each bite of a well-crafted bagel can transport you to a bustling New York deli or evoke memories of lazy Sunday brunches. In this charming town, the bagel scene brings together freshness, tradition, and a bit of local flair. As a fan of a good bagel myself, I’ve scoured the area to find some standout spots that promise not just flavor, but also a welcoming atmosphere and a commitment to quality.
From the moment you walk into a bagel shop in Eastham, the aroma hits you—a delightful mix of baking dough and steaming coffee. It’s a sensory experience that sets the stage for what’s to come. In this guide, I’ll introduce you to the top bagel hotspots in Eastham, highlighting not only their delicious offerings but also what makes each unique. Whether you’re here for a quick breakfast or a relaxed meal, you’ll leave inspired to savor every crispy, chewy bite. Let’s dive into where you can find these bagel gems in Eastham, MA.
1. Hole In One Bakery & Coffee Shop
Hole In One Bakery & Coffee Shop offers a delightful experience for bagel lovers in Eastham. With its commitment to quality, this cafe crafts bagels that are hand-cut and baked daily, ensuring a fresh and tasty bite every time. The inviting atmosphere makes it an ideal spot to grab a warm bagel while sipping on one of their expertly brewed coffees.
What truly sets Hole In One apart is its range of delicious options. Their classic plain and everything bagels are a must-try, often paired with house-made cream cheese that enhances the whole experience. Feeling adventurous? Go for their bagel sandwiches, featuring fresh ingredients that highlight the bakery’s dedication to quality and flavor.
For a complete breakfast, don’t miss the opportunity to enjoy their bagels with a steaming cup of gourmet coffee. This combination will leave you refreshed and ready to explore the beauty of Cape Cod. Make sure to swing by and indulge in this local favorite.
2. Laura & Tony’s Kitchen
Laura & Tony’s Kitchen brings a fresh, homemade approach to Eastham’s breakfast scene. Their commitment to slow food—prepared from scratch in small batches—means every bite carries intention. I still remember the first time I tried their everything bagel; the perfect crust gave way to a satisfyingly chewy center that made it clear these weren’t mass-produced.
What makes this spot special is their thoughtful inclusivity. Alongside traditional options, they offer standout gluten-free and plant-based bagel varieties—a rarity in Cape Cod’s breakfast landscape. Their house-made cashew cream cheese (available upon request) pairs beautifully with their seeded bagels, creating a dairy-free option that doesn’t compromise on richness.
For the full experience, order their bagel breakfast sandwich with avocado and heirloom tomato, then pair it with their organic Sumatra coffee. The care in their preparation turns a simple bagel into something memorable—just like the rest of their seasonal, locally-focused menu.
Frequently Asked Questions
Q: Where can I find the best bagels in Eastham, MA?
A: Hole In One Bakery & Coffee Shop and Laura & Tony’s Kitchen are top choices, offering fresh, handcrafted bagels with unique flavors and high-quality ingredients.
Q: Do any bagel spots in Eastham offer gluten-free or vegan options?
A: Yes! Laura & Tony’s Kitchen provides gluten-free and plant-based bagel options, along with dairy-free spreads like cashew cream cheese.
Q: What’s the best time to visit for fresh bagels?
A: Early morning is ideal, especially on weekends, as popular spots like Hole In One tend to sell out of certain flavors by mid-morning.
Q: Can I get a bagel breakfast sandwich in Eastham?
A: Absolutely. Both Hole In One and Laura & Tony’s Kitchen serve hearty bagel sandwiches with fresh toppings like avocado, eggs, and locally sourced ingredients.
Q: Are there any halal-friendly bagel options in Eastham?
A: While neither bakery is halal, Laura & Tony’s Kitchen offers plant-based and dairy-free options that may align with dietary preferences. Always confirm ingredients when ordering.
Q: Do these places offer coffee or drinks with bagels?
A: Yes—Hole In One serves gourmet coffee, while Laura & Tony’s features organic Sumatra coffee, cold-pressed juices, and even brunch cocktails like mimosas.
Q: Is seating available, or are these mostly takeout spots?
A: Both have seating, but Laura & Tony’s cozy atmosphere makes it great for lingering, while Hole In One is more grab-and-go friendly.
