Best Bagels in Commack, NY

When it comes to bagels, Commack, NY, has some real gems. I’ve tasted a lot of bagels in my day, and trust me, these places stand out. This guide will help you find the best.

So, what are the best bagels in Commack, NY? The top choices are Bagel Chalet, Commack Bagels Deli Market, Everything Bagel, Bagel Basket Cafe, Bagel Toasterie, House of Bagels, Princess Deli, First Class Bagels, Bagelport E. Northport NY, and Bagel Boss of East Northport. Each spot offers unique flavors and textures that you’ll love.

I can’t wait to share my experiences at these bagel shops with you. You’re in for a treat! Stick around to discover where to get your next favorite bagel.

Top 10 Bagels in Commack, NY

1. Bagel Chalet
2. Commack Bagels Deli Market
3. Everything Bagel
4. Bagel Basket Cafe
5. BAGEL TOASTERIE
6. House of Bagels
7. Princess Deli
8. First Class Bagels
9. Bagelport E.Northport NY
10. Bagel Boss of East Northport

1. Bagel Chalet

You’ll find Bagel Chalet at 36 Veterans Memorial Hwy, Commack, NY. It’s a chill spot with both indoor and outdoor seating. You can even order for delivery or takeout. The place is wheelchair-accessible too.

What makes Bagel Chalet stand out? It’s their simple yet amazing menu. They’ve got bagels, breakfast dishes, sandwiches, and salads. Prices are moderate, so you won’t break the bank.

When I visited, I was wowed by their bagels. They were fresh and chewy. My top pick? Their Everything Bagel with lox and cream cheese. It’s a must-try! If you want something heartier, go for a breakfast sandwich. They’re awesome.

So, if you’re in Commack, don’t miss out on Bagel Chalet. It’s a bagel lover’s paradise!

2. Commack Bagels Deli Market

Commack Bagels Deli Market is at 260 Commack Rd, Commack, NY. They have delivery, takeout, and both indoor and outdoor seating. The entrance is wheelchair-accessible too.

Commack Bagels Deli Market stands out for its affordable prices and wide variety. You can get delicious bagels and deli options without spending a lot.

I had a great time there. The bagels were super fresh and tasty. My favorite was the plain bagel with vegetable cream cheese. It’s simple but so good. If you’re hungrier, go for their breakfast bagel sandwich. It’s hearty and yummy.

So, if you’re in Commack, check out Commack Bagels Deli Market. It’s budget-friendly and has awesome bagels!

3. Everything Bagel

So, Everything Bagel is this amazing spot at 217 Commack Rd, Commack, NY. Picture a warm, cozy place where you can relax. The prices? Super affordable.

I always go for their sesame bagel with lox spread. It’s like biting into a little slice of heaven. Crispy outside, soft inside. Just perfect.

What makes Everything Bagel special? Their service. The staff is quick and friendly. Plus, they’ve got something for everyone.

If you visit, you must try the sesame bagel with lox spread. Trust me, it’s the best. You’ll love it!

4. Bagel Basket Cafe

Bagel Basket Cafe is located at 639 Commack Rd, Commack, NY. It’s a cozy place with a great vibe. You can sit inside or out, which is nice. They even take reservations. Prices are pretty moderate here.

When I visited, I was impressed. Their bagels were fresh and warm. I tried the egg everything bagel, and it blew me away! So much flavor in every bite.

What really makes Bagel Basket Cafe stand out? They have a fantastic variety of bagels and sandwiches. The staff is super friendly and helpful.

If you go, definitely get the egg everything bagel. It’s a great choice that shows off their skills. You’ll love it!

5. BAGEL TOASTERIE

BAGEL TOASTERIE is at the Mayfair Shopping Center, 20-2020 Jericho Turnpike, Commack, NY. It’s a bright and cheerful place. You can sit indoors or enjoy the outdoors. Best part? The prices are super cheap!

When I visited, I had a blast. The bagels were fresh and so warm. I tried their cinnamon raisin bagel with honey spread. Let me tell you, it was amazing!

What really makes BAGEL TOASTERIE special? The friendly atmosphere and quick service! They make you feel right at home.

If you drop by, order the cinnamon raisin bagel. It’s sweet and perfect for any time of day. You’ll love it, trust me!

6. House of Bagels

House of Bagels is super cozy. It’s right on 4 Vanderbilt Motor Pkwy, Commack. They do delivery and takeout. Prices are nice and cheap too.

I went there recently. The bagels were warm and fresh. I got a garlic bagel with cream cheese. It was so good!

What’s cool about this place? Tons of flavors. You’ll always find something new to try.

If you go, get the garlic bagel with cream cheese. It’s tasty and satisfying. You’ll love it!

7. Princess Deli

Princess Deli is at 1151 Jericho Turnpike, Commack, NY. They offer delivery and takeout. The prices are pretty moderate, which is nice. The place has a cozy vibe.

I recently stopped by, and I loved it! I tried an everything bagel with scallion cream cheese. Wow, it was fresh and tasty. The bagel had the perfect crunch and softness. The cream cheese added a nice flavor.

What makes Princess Deli special? They really care about quality. The staff was super nice and helpful. If you visit, definitely order the lox and cream cheese bagel. It’s a total winner and shows off their great style!

8. First Class Bagels

First Class Bagels is at 1922 Jericho Turnpike in East Northport, NY. It’s a nice spot with indoor and outdoor seating. They also offer delivery and takeout, which is great.

When I went there, I was impressed. The bagels were super fresh and fluffy. I tried the everything bagel, toasted with cream cheese. Wow, it was so good!

What really makes First Class Bagels special? It’s their focus on quality. The staff is friendly and helpful too. If you’re there, definitely try the toasted everything bagel. It’s a tasty, perfect choice that shows off their style!

9. Bagelport E.Northport NY

Bagelport E. Northport is at 290 Larkfield Rd, East Northport, NY. This place feels cozy and friendly. You can sit inside or outside. Plus, it’s cheap and great for takeout.

When I went there, I had a blast. The bagels were super fresh! I tried a poppy seed bagel with cream cheese. Wow, it was delicious!

What really stands out at Bagelport is the warm vibe. The staff is nice and welcoming. If you stop by, definitely get the poppy seed bagel. It’s a simple choice that shows off their quality. You’re going to love it!

10. Bagel Boss of East Northport

Bagel Boss of East Northport is located at 1941 Jericho Turnpike. It’s a popular spot for bagel lovers. They have delivery and takeout options, plus nice indoor and outdoor seating. Prices are moderate, which is great.

When I stopped by, I was impressed. The bagels were fresh and soft. I ordered a classic plain bagel with cream cheese. It was super tasty!

What really stands out at Bagel Boss? The huge selection and friendly staff. The vibe is warm and welcoming. If you visit, definitely try the classic plain bagel. It shows off their quality so well. You’re going to love it!

Map of Bagels in Commack, NY

Choosing the Right Shop for You

With 10 excellent places, here’s a quick comparison to help you decide:

Frequently Asked Questions

Where can I find the best bagels in Commack, NY?

If you’re looking for great bagels, try Bagel Chalet or Everything Bagel. They always have fresh, tasty options.

What are some popular bagel flavors in Commack?

You can’t go wrong with classic flavors like everything and sesame. Many places also have fun specialty flavors worth trying!

Are there gluten-free bagel options?

Yes, some shops offer gluten-free bagels. Call ahead to check what’s available at places like Bagel Basket Cafe.

Do any bagel shops offer catering services?

Absolutely! Many places, like Bagel Boss, do catering. It’s great for events and gatherings.

What are the hours for bagel shops in Commack?

Hours can vary, but most open early and close in the afternoon. Check their websites for exact times.

Can I order bagels online for delivery?

Yes! Many shops provide online ordering and delivery. Just check their websites or use delivery apps.

Are there vegan bagel options in Commack?

Some shops have vegan bagels and spreads. It’s best to ask when you go in!

What are the best bagel toppings?

I love cream cheese, lox, and avocado. Each shop has its own special toppings, so explore a bit!

Do bagel shops in Commack have seating?

Most have seating options. It’s nice to sit and enjoy your bagel with a friend.

Can I get breakfast sandwiches at these shops?

For sure! Lots of places like Bagel Chalet have tasty breakfast sandwiches. They’re perfect for a morning treat.