I’ve had my fair share of bagels in Bellmore, NY. Trust me, it’s a delightful journey. I’ve tasted some of the best bagels around. And I’m excited to share my favorites with you.
If you’re on the hunt for the best bagels in Bellmore, NY, you’re in for a treat. There’s a fantastic variety of bagels here. From classic to unique flavors, each shop has its own twist. You will taste freshness in every bite.
Get ready for a fun ride through Bellmore’s bagel scene. I’ll share my top picks and what makes each spot special. You won’t want to miss any of these delicious finds!
Top 10 Bagels in Bellmore, NY
- Long Island Bagel Cafe
- Town Bagel
- Lotsa Bagels & Deli
- Soul Brew Bellmore
- South Shore Bagels
- Bagel Chalet – Merrick
- Bagel Boss Cafe
- BagelMan-Deliman
- The Bagel Place
- Wantagh Bagels
1. Long Island Bagel Cafe
Phone: (516) 781-6575
Menu: libc.com
Directions: Open on Map
Long Island Bagel Cafe, at 550-552 Jerusalem Ave, Bellmore, NY, is a must-visit. They offer delivery, indoor and outdoor seating, and takeout. Plus, it’s wheelchair-accessible, which is great!
I loved the cozy vibe and friendly staff. The smell of fresh bagels was amazing.
Their variety and quality are top-notch. The bagels are fresh, chewy, and delicious.
Try the everything bagel with scallion cream cheese. It’s a perfect combo and truly highlights their bagel-making skills.
2. Town Bagel
Phone: (516) 785-8986
Menu: www.townbagel.com
Directions: Open on Map
Town Bagel at 2729 Merrick Rd, Bellmore, NY, is a go-to spot. They offer delivery, indoor and outdoor seating, and takeout. The place is also wheelchair-accessible, which is great for everyone.
I had a blast visiting. The atmosphere was warm and welcoming. The smell of fresh bagels lured me in.
Town Bagel stands out for its wide variety and top quality. Each bagel is fresh and full of flavor.
Try the onion bagel with cream cheese. It’s simple but so tasty. You’ll see why Town Bagel is a local favorite!
3. Lotsa Bagels & Deli
Lotsa Bagels & Deli, at 2474 Jerusalem Ave, North Bellmore, NY, is a gem. They offer both delivery and takeout. The place is wheelchair-accessible too.
When I visited, I felt right at home. The staff were super friendly. The smell of fresh bagels was heavenly.
What makes them special? Their huge selection and top-notch quality. Every bagel is soft and tasty.
I loved the cinnamon raisin bagel with cream cheese. It’s sweet, warm, and delicious. Trust me, you’ll love it. Lotsa Bagels & Deli is a true hidden gem!
4. Soul Brew Bellmore
Phone: (516) 804-4624
Menu: soulbrew.coffee
Directions: Open on Map
Soul Brew Bellmore is at 2718 Grand Ave, and it’s a great spot. They offer delivery and takeout, and you can sit inside or outside. Plus, the entrance is wheelchair-accessible, which is awesome.
When I walked in, it felt so inviting. The place has a cozy and cool vibe. The staff were super friendly, making me feel right at home. And the bagels? Amazing!
What I love about Soul Brew is their unique menu. Each dish is made with fresh ingredients. You can really taste the quality.
You have to try their avocado toast bagel. It’s fresh and so delicious! Also, the lox bagel is a must. It has the perfect mix of flavors. You won’t be disappointed!
5. South Shore Bagels
South Shore Bagels is at 3451 Merrick Rd, and it’s fantastic! They have delivery and takeout options. You can enjoy indoor or outdoor seating too. The entrance is wheelchair-accessible, which is super helpful.
When I visited, I felt the good vibes right away. The staff were friendly and welcoming. The smell of fresh bagels made my mouth water!
What makes South Shore Bagels stand out is their variety. Every bagel is fresh and bursting with flavor.
I highly recommend the everything bagel with cream cheese. It’s simply delicious! If you’re hungry, try the bacon, egg, and cheese bagel. It’s hearty and so tasty. You won’t regret visiting!
6. Bagel Chalet – Merrick
Phone: (516) 378-3300
Menu: bagelchalet.com
Directions: Open on Map
Bagel Chalet – Merrick is at 2037 Merrick Rd, and it’s a lovely spot. They offer delivery and takeout, plus indoor and outdoor seating. The entrance is wheelchair-accessible, which is a nice touch.
I walked in and was hit with the amazing smell of fresh bagels. The vibe was warm and inviting. Everyone was friendly, making me feel right at home.
What really stands out is their quality. Each bagel is soft and full of flavor. I tried the Everything Bagel with lox and cream cheese. Wow! It was delicious—a perfect mix of tastes.
If you go, don’t miss the Egg Everything Bagel. It’s super tasty and shows how good they are at what they do. You’ll love it!
7. Bagel Boss Cafe
Phone: (516) 442-3006
Menu: www.bagelbossmerrick.com
Directions: Open on Map
Bagel Boss Cafe is at 2101 Merrick Rd in Merrick, NY, and it’s such a great place! The moment I walked in, I was hit with the warm smell of fresh bagels. It felt cozy and inviting.
The staff welcomed me with big smiles. I decided to try the Everything Bagel with cream cheese. Wow! It was perfectly toasted, and the flavor was amazing.
What I love about Bagel Boss Cafe is their variety. They have so many options to choose from. Plus, they offer indoor and outdoor seating, plus delivery. The entrance is also wheelchair-accessible, which is a bonus.
If you’re looking for something sweet, try the Cinnamon Raisin Bagel with butter. It’s delicious and really shows their commitment to quality. You won’t be disappointed!
8. BagelMan-Deliman
BagelMan-Deliman is at 84 Merrick Ave, Merrick, NY. They offer delivery and takeout. You can sit inside or outside. The entrance is wheelchair accessible.
When I visited, I felt welcomed. The place was vibrant and lively. The bagels looked fresh. I tried the Plain Bagel with cream cheese. It was soft and very yummy.
What sets BagelMan-Deliman apart? Their friendly service and variety. The atmosphere is fun and inviting.
If you want something special, try the Spinach Feta Bagel. It’s packed with flavor. It shows their creative touch.
9. The Bagel Place
Phone: (516) 565-3917
Menu: www.thebagelplacecaterers.com
Directions: Open on Map
Let me tell you about The Bagel Place. It’s located at 487 Bellmore Ave, East Meadow, NY. They have delivery, takeout, and cozy indoor and outdoor seating. The entrance is also wheelchair-accessible.
When I went there, I felt right at home. The people were super friendly, and the bagels looked fantastic. I tried the French Toast Bagel, and oh my goodness, it was incredible. Sweet, soft, and just the right amount of cinnamon.
What makes The Bagel Place special? It’s their creativity. They offer unique flavors you won’t find anywhere else.
You should try the creamy chive spread. It’s amazing and makes any bagel taste even better. Trust me, you’ll love it here!
10. Wantagh Bagels
Phone: (516) 781-2244
Menu: order.online
Directions: Open on Map
Wantagh Bagels is at 3056 Merrick Rd in Wantagh, NY. This place is super cozy and inviting. They have indoor and outdoor seating, plus delivery and takeout. The entrance is wheelchair-accessible, which is really nice.
When I walked in, I was greeted with smiles. The smell of fresh bagels made my mouth water! I decided to try their Everything Bagel with lox and cream cheese. Oh wow, it was so good. The flavors just popped!
What I love about Wantagh Bagels is their variety. They really take pride in their quality. If you’re looking for a great breakfast, try the bacon, egg, and cheese bagel. It’s a classic and done perfectly. You won’t be disappointed!
Map of Bagels in Bellmore, NY
Choosing the Right Shop for You
With 10 excellent places, here’s a quick comparison to help you decide:
| Shop | Price | Seating | Takeout | Delivery | Wheelchair | Reservation |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Long Island Bagel Cafe | Inexpensive | Yes | Yes | Yes | Accessible | – |
| Town Bagel | Inexpensive | Yes | Yes | Yes | Accessible | – |
| Lotsa Bagels & Deli | – | – | Yes | Yes | Accessible | – |
| Soul Brew Bellmore | Inexpensive | Yes | Yes | Yes | Accessible | – |
| South Shore Bagels | Inexpensive | Yes | Yes | Yes | Accessible | – |
| Bagel Chalet – Merrick | Inexpensive | Yes | Yes | Yes | Accessible | – |
| Bagel Boss Cafe | Moderate | Yes | Yes | Yes | Accessible | – |
| BagelMan-Deliman | – | Yes | Yes | Yes | Accessible | – |
| The Bagel Place | Inexpensive | Yes | Yes | Yes | Accessible | – |
| Wantagh Bagels | Inexpensive | Yes | Yes | Yes | Accessible | – |
Frequently Asked Questions
1. What are the best bagel spots in Bellmore, NY?
I’d say Long Island Bagel Cafe and Town Bagel are top favorites. Both serve delicious bagels and have great atmospheres!
2. Do the bagel shops offer delivery?
Yes, many bagel shops in Bellmore do delivery. It makes enjoying bagels at home super easy!
3. Are the bagel shops wheelchair-accessible?
Most bagel shops are wheelchair-accessible. It’s great because everyone can enjoy a tasty bagel!
4. What bagel flavors should I try?
You can’t go wrong with everything, cinnamon raisin, or plain. I’ve also loved trying bagels with unique flavors!
5. Can I customize my bagel?
Definitely! You can choose your bagel flavor and add all sorts of toppings.
6. What are good toppings for bagels?
Cream cheese, lox, and avocado are all popular. I also enjoy spreads like hummus or butter!
7. How much do bagels cost in Bellmore?
Bagels are usually inexpensive. You can find them from $1 to $2 each, depending on what you get.
8. Are there vegetarian or vegan options?
Yes, many bagel shops have vegetarian and vegan options. Just ask, and they’ll help you find something delicious!
