When it comes to bagels in Atlantic Highlands, NJ, trust me, I’ve done the homework. With years of noshing on these doughy delights, I know my bagels inside and out. So, get ready for the lowdown on the best bagels you’ll ever taste.

Looking for the best bagels in Atlantic Highlands, NJ? You’re in luck. This place offers bagels with the perfect blend of chewiness and flavor. Crafted with love and top-notch ingredients. You won’t find better.
Ready to uncover the hidden gems of this coastal town? Keep reading! From classic favorites to unique finds, this guide has it all. Discover the bagels that will make your mornings a whole lot better.
Atlantic Bagel Co.
Atlantic Bagel Co. is at 74 First Ave. It’s cozy and inviting. You can sit inside or outside. Prices won’t break the bank. They offer takeout too. The entrance is wheelchair-accessible.
I visited and felt right at home. The staff was super friendly. The service was quick. The bagels were fresh. They had the perfect chewiness and flavor. I loved every bite.
What makes Atlantic Bagel Co. special? It’s their high-quality ingredients and traditional methods. Their bagels have a unique taste that you won’t find elsewhere.
If you go, try the everything bagel with cream cheese. It’s the best! And don’t miss the bacon, egg, and cheese bagel. It’s a breakfast dream come true.
Map of Bagels in Atlantic Highlands, NJ
Choosing the Right Shop for You
With 1 excellent places, here’s a quick comparison to help you decide:
Shop | Price | Seating | Takeout | Delivery | Wheelchair | Reservation |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Atlantic Bagel Co. | Inexpensive | Yes | Yes | No | Accessible | – |
Frequently Asked Questions
1. Where’s the best place for bagels in Atlantic Highlands, NJ?
I’d say Atlantic Bagel Co. is the spot. They make amazing bagels, fresh every day!
2. What bagels should I definitely try there?
You can’t go wrong with the everything bagel and cream cheese. And if you’re hungry, get the bacon, egg, and cheese bagel—it’s awesome!
3. Are there gluten-free bagels available?
Yes! Some places offer gluten-free options. It’s best to call and check first.
4. How much do bagels cost at Atlantic Bagel Co.?
Prices are really reasonable. You get tasty bagels without spending too much.
5. Is it easy to access Atlantic Bagel Co. for everyone?
Definitely! The entrance is wheelchair-accessible, so everyone can enjoy it.
6. Can I grab my bagels to go?
Absolutely! They have takeout options. Perfect for when you’re in a hurry.
7. What time does Atlantic Bagel Co. open?
They usually open early and close in the afternoon. I suggest checking their website for exact hours.
8. Do they have vegan bagel options?
Yes! They offer some vegan choices too. Just ask about what they have.
9. Are there other good bagel spots nearby?
For sure! There are a few other great places to grab bagels. Each one has its own twist.
10. Can I order online?
Yes, you can! They let you place online orders for pickup. Just check their website for more info.